Horses & Food Safety

  

               
              Please visit our Facebook page for the most up-to-date news  


                     

The following information is fact based sourceable documentation that has been compiled from a number of resources including government sites [in and out of country], medical journals, European Union FVO reports, white papers and veterinary publications.
           
           
Editorials and Investigations relating to horses and food safety can be found on the Horse Slaughter page and Press Release page on this site. Slides discussing food safety are available on the Presentations page. 
 




 Recognizing the dangers of horse meat to our food supply and foreign consumers,
 the USDA, with unprecedented action, has included language in the FY 14 budget 
 that defunds horse inspections. The below language is on page 197 of the
 Department of Agriculture
Appendix.

  

SEC. 725. None of the funds made available in this Act may be used to pay the salaries or expenses of personnel to-(1) inspect horses under section 3 of the Federal Meat Inspection Act (21 U.S.C. 603); (2) inspect horses under section 903 of the Federal Agriculture Improvement and Reform Act of 1996 (7 U.S.C. 1901 note; Public Law 104127); or (3) implement or enforce section 352.19 of title 9, Code of Federal Regulations.

   


 
 
Congressional Letter to President Obama [May 15, 2013]



 


 
  The global horse meat scandal is raging after meat labeled as beef was found to
  contain horse meat in Ireland and the UK. The proven health risks of drugs given
  to horses as well as fraud are being researched, investigated and evaluated. As of
  February 15, 2013, three people have been arrested. The number of countries
  impacted continues to grow. The articles and statements are too numerous to list
  here as there are literally hundreds and hundreds across the globe.

  The countries involved, thus far, are listed below [in alpha order]. The silence
  is deafening from the US meat industry leading us to believe this scandal is far
  from over.

  It should be noted that the USDA stated that the scandal is not happening in the
  US because we don't have horse slaughter plants.



  A synopsis and list of recalls can be found here
 


Austria
Belgium
Bulgaria
Cyprus
Czech Republic
Denmark
Dominican Republic
France
Finland
Germany
Greece
Hong Kong
Hungary
Ireland
Italy
Luxembourg
Netherlands
Norway
Poland
Portugal
Romania
Scotland
Slovakia
Slovenia
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
Thailand
UK

Major Businesses Impacted:

Aldi
Birds Eye
Burger King
Ikea
Nestles
Taco Bell
Wal-Mart 


                          


 67% of the horse meat exported to the European Union [EU] from Canada is from
 US horses. It is estimated that between Canada and Mexico, US horses represent
 over 80% of the exported horse meat to the EU. The exports to the EU of US 
 horses represents an insignificant percentage of the EU market.


 As a perspective, the exports from Cavel, the last of the three US slaughter plants
 that closed on September 21 2007, represented less than 1% of Velda's (Belgium 
 parent company) market. 
 

            Source: 7th Circuit Court of Appeals.

 

   
 2013 European Union Regulations governing exports to the EU  
          note: all equines will require passports
  
     2009 published EU Regulations to allow exporting countries to meet full
     compliance by 2013
.

     Please note that page 3, 3rd paragraph states all wild equidae meat is
     prohibited except zebra meat.
                
                   
 
 Testing Protocol | USDA - FSIS Confirmation of Phenylbutazone

 

The following links are published papers and studies on phenylbutazone [bute], a commonly used medication for horses that is banned in all food animals. The below documentation details the dangers of horse meat containing bute.

 Food and Chemical Toxicology Drug Paper
            
     
          Appendix: Corrected Links

               
    We would be remiss in not including the below letter submitted late in
     2010 that unsuccessfully attempted to discredit this paper.


     This is the letter along with
Dr. Marini's responseDr. Marini's response was 
      accepted by the journal as validation of the paper, thus dismissing the
      attempt to discredit the paper. Had there been any validity to the letter,
      the original paper would have been corrected.


      
 Ireland Veterinary White Paper on Phenylbutazone

 Canadian Food Inspection Agency: Horse Slaughter Health Requirements
   Note: prohibited medications are listed in this document

 University of Delaware | Horse Meat Food Safety Concerns
 An Investigation into the availability of horse meat in Belgium, France and
 the Netherlands





  The following links are EU FVO reports, food safety investigations and
   a few recent recalls on horse meat containing phenylbutazone.


   Note: the EU FVO reports have a common trend in that banned
    substances are present in US horses slaughtered in Canada and Mexico
    and that the health papers accompanying the horses are falsified. The
    most recent report from Mexico states that health affidavits are not
    sufficient to meet EU standards.

     


  EU FVO Report on Equines Slaughtered in Mexico - 2012
  
  European Union FVO reports from late 2010, released in 2011:

  Mexico:
    Vivian Grant Summary     

    Animals' Angels Summary
     

    Full FVO Report


             
  Canada:
    Animals' Angels Summary     

   
Full FVO Report

   This is Canada's response


  Proof of CFIA Failure
    
Summary

    Full Investigation

 
 Recent Recalls
 UK
 Canada
 UK

 

 The following articles are from investigative reporters and journalists
 
 Latitude News | The Shady trade in American horse meat
 New York Times | Joe Drape: Drugs injected at the Racetrack Put Europe Off
 U.S. Horse Meat
 Horse Meat: A Dangerous `Delicacy' [from the print edition of Natural Horse]
      note: this is a large file and may take a while to open
 





   EWA Website Design and Image Copyright(c) Terry Fitch